Butter Blanket Turkey
Everyone has their own way of doing their Thanksgiving turkey. In our household, butter soaked cheesecloth is the only way we would ever do it.
Turkeys require some TLC before hand to ensure the bird stays flavorful and juicy. Dry brine 1-2 nights before with kosher salt or jazz it up with other herbs and zest. We went a little more classic this year with the home grown herb compound butter. The cheesecloth also helps the herbs stick to the skin instead of falling off with the butter.
Don’t forget to make stock with the turkey carcass as it’s loaded with connective tissue, fat and collagen. This will also make your gravy have so much flavor next year if you freeze it.
TOTAL PREP TIME: 24 - 30 Hours
TOTAL COOK TIME: 5 - 6 Hours
EQUIPMENT:
Large roasting pan with handles
Turkey rack
Cheesecloth
Fat seperater
Sifter or fine strainer
Meat thermometer
Baster
INGREDIENTS:
12 lb Turkey
5 or more sticks of high quality unsalted butter
Fresh herbs
2 bulbs of garlic
2-3 onions or shallots
2-3 cups of broth
1/2 cup of flour (adjust depending on amount of fat)
Citrus
Kosher salt
Peppercorns
White wine (optional)
DRY BRINE (night before):
Rinse turkey thoroughly and pat dry
Heavily salt the turkey one to two nights before cooking. One tablespoons per 4 lbs of turkey (make sure scrub the salt into the skin and don’t forget to salt the cavity too)
Cover with plastic wrap or put in large bag and leave in the fridge overnight
Take out turkey at least 3 hours before cooking to come to room temperature
Pat turkey dry, no need to rinse
SEASONING:
Preheat oven to 450 degrees
Mix finely chopped herbs in softened butter (can be made well in advance)
Spread compound butter all the over turkey
If you can, spread some under the skin (the skin can be hard to separate so feel free to skip)
Stuff the cavity with citrus, onion, garlic, whole peppercorns and herbs
Fully soak cheesecloth in 1 -2 sticks of unsalted butter
Drape over whole turkey with at least 2 layers of soaked cheesecloth
ROASTING:
Put the turkey in the oven for 30-35 minutes
Take out of the oven and baste well
Lower the oven temp to 350 degrees
Put the turkey back in the oven for another 2 hours basting every 30 minutes
The turkey is ready once the internal temp in the deepest part of the thigh or breast is 160 degrees
Transfer turkey to another pan or tray
Let rest for about 30 minutes to an hour (don’t worry it will still be hot)
GRAVY:
Pour broth, wine or water into roasting tray to deglaze and scrape the frond off the bottom of the pan
Pour mixture into fat separator
Pour only the fat into a medium sauce pan and add sifted flour and cook on medium heat until darkened
Deglaze with a small amount broth, wine or water then add the rest of the both into the pan.
Let cook down until thickened
Add salt and pepper at the very end to taste
CARVING:
Cut or rip wings and drumsticks off first
Slice breasts off next
Then you can flip the bird over and carve the dark meat (a smaller knife can get into the hard to reach areas)
Place sliced turkey on a warmed platter and serve with the crispy skin